In2SciFi

Does it? See my own thoughts as part of the thread ‘Quantity Leads to Quality‘ in Ben Long’s blog.

I think this discussion will continue forever.

I recently purchased Adobe’s Lightroom after trialing both it and Apple’s Aperture. I chose Lightroom because it’s mix of features best matched my own working style, though both packages had something unique that they brought to the table. Since I purchased it, I’ve been reading books and talking to people about Lightroom, trying to learn to use it as well as I possibly can.

In the process of talking to other people using Lightroom, I’ve run across what almost seems to be an assumption that Lightroom can only be used with Photoshop as an external editor. Certainly, in what I’ve read, when the external editor is mentioned, the author goes into Photoshop. However, Adobe was smarter than this because not only can you change the primary editor Lightroom will use, but you can also configure a 2nd editor for use with Lightroom. That leaves us open for lots of possibilities. One of the more interesting ones for people who can’t afford Photoshop is GIMP.

If you go to the Lightroom Preferences, you’ll find a configuration for an Additional External Editor. I selected GIMP and configured Lightroom to pass the file to it as an 8-bit, Adobe RGB(1998) file at as resolution of 240 using ZIP compression:

As a simple trial, I selected a picture I recently took and went to the ‘Photo->Edit In’ menu from which I was now able to select either Photoshop or GIMP. Selecting GIMP automatically started the required X-Windows environment under OSX and then GIMP itself:

On doing a very simple edit, in this case just cropping the image to make it easy to see when I got back to Lightroom, I saved the image (which now has -edit added to the end of the name) and came back to Lightroom where it shows up next to the original image which is still selected.

OK … so I can use another editor or even two editors, why would I want to?? There are several reasons to add this to your toolkit:

• I find that there are some things I can do easier or better in one editor than in another. For example, I can write special processing for an image in Python or LISP in GIMP and execute that on my image.
• You may not be able to purchase Photoshop or you may prefer another editor for creative editing.

As I spend more time with the application, I’m also finding new and interesting ways to use it. I’ll report on some of the other options as I go on. One of the interesting features is the ability to save presets with configurations you like, so here’s an image I’ve used for testing a variety of B&W conversions:

Here is a very simple, yet custom, B&W conversion of this image done simply by choosing a preset!

I’ve recently posted an article at

http://digital-photography-school.com/forum/tutorials/103652-lightroom-external-editing.html

about using Lightroom with other editors, specifically GIMP. I’ve also posted an extended article here in this blog.

I plan to say more about Lightroom as I go forward.